6 Comments

Twitter V LinkedIn: Much Ado About Nothing?


There has been a lot of noise over the last week about Twitter revoking access to their API to LinkedIn. It was billed as a battle of the social media channels, with Twitter choosing to flex their not inconsiderable muscle towards LinkedIn and taking a stand. Most of what was written was actually rubbish. I was surprised by the quality of some of the names who chose to get involved. Lets take a close look at what has actually happened.

Twitter have chosen to disable a feature that was massively unpopular. That being the ability to post tweets direct to your LinkedIn profile. A few months ago LinkedIn chose to remove the twitter app from those available to use with your profile. The reason given was that the users hardly used it and it was only cluttering up the app suite. On the most part this app was preety useless, as it only served to add tweets as a constant stream of updates. This practice was hugely unpopular with LinkedIn users who got a flooded stream of mostly irrelevance. I turned this off when I installed the app, though I did like having the facility to see which LinkedIn connections I had that I didn’t follow, so that I could follow them. I would like to see that facility back in either channel, or some other app. It could be that Twitter chose to remove some access in retaliation for the removal of this app. The only other change is that I can no longer update my LinkedIn profile by adding #In to my tweets. Again that is brilliant, because I occasionally retweeted a blog post and left #In in the title, inadvertently updating my profile with someone elses content. I never used this feature because I always wanted to add an image to my updates (you get a lot more opens when you do), and I can only do this from LinkedIn.

I can still post LinkedIn updates to Twitter from my profile, groups, comments, polls, questions, jobs etc. Sharing the LinkedIn link from updates is more valuable because retweets count as shares in the algorythm that calculates and promotes trending content to other users. For me at least, the changes mean business as usual, and it is my LinkedIn user experience that is improved by removing the tweets from the updates.

Looking at the wider picture though, Twitter taking a tighter, LinkedIn like stance over the use of their API may have other ramifications for other applications. If, for example, they were to introduce a non-compete clause as with LinkedIn, might we see the end of applications like Hootsuite that compete with Twitter owned Tweetdeck? I should think other apps that currently export Twitter profiles and data to other locations will also be sweating a bit, and there are quite a few of those. Could be that Twitter feel they have now achieved a critical mass of 100million users, and want users to stay in the channel, rather than work outside of it. Time will tell,

Interesting times ahead, but does this change impact on me now? No, not really. It is much-a-do about nothing for now, at least.

Bill

6 comments on “Twitter V LinkedIn: Much Ado About Nothing?

  1. It’s all about the Twitter Twitter Experience – as explained here: http://ow.ly/c1kW2

  2. Personally I lost quite much. I have very different connections in Linkedin then in Twitter and now that “second Twitter feed” totally disappeared. Linkedin is now almost like Google+ and I have very few reasons to visit the site. LinkedIn Today was as well much relaying on this content as I know so again big hit to Linkedin as they want to still be “a social/professional network” not only the reference point. Interesting to see what there is to come in terms of more news about Twitter API…

  3. […] media channels, with Twitter choosing to flex their not inconsiderable muscle towards …See on recruitingunblog.wordpress.com Share this:FacebookTwitterLinkedInLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. This entry was posted […]

  4. Bill, excellent analysis of this tempest in a teacup, esp the ramifications for other services. I like LinkedIn for what it does–which is not Twitter. They’re in my view more different than either are vis a vis Facebook.

  5. Nice article Bill. As always. Personally Im finding a bit inconvenient nothing more>

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: